Table of content
The short answer: Mild pain during exercise is often acceptable if it stays steady and settles by the next morning. A simple rule: green is pain at or below 3 out of 10, yellow is 4 to 5, so ease the load, and red is 6 or higher, or any sharp, sudden or worsening pain, so stop. Warning signs always override the rule.
Key takeaways
- Hurt is not always harm. A review of 7 randomized trials in chronic musculoskeletal pain found painful and pain-free exercise ended up with similar results over the medium and long term.
- "Acceptable" has limits. In a well-known tendon rehab study, pain had to stay below 5 out of 10 during exercise and settle by the next morning.
- Check three times. The Arthritis Foundation advises checking pain before, during and 24 hours after exercise.
- Sharp, sudden or persistent pain means stop. Cleveland Clinic says not to push through it.
- The traffic light is our simplification. The 5 out of 10 limit comes from research. The 3 out of 10 green line is our own choice and is not a validated cutoff.
- Warning signs always win. Numbness, weakness, bladder or bowel changes, or pain after a fall are not "exercise pain."
If you have ever wondered whether to keep going when a move hurts, you are in good company. "No pain, no gain" can be wrong, and so can "stop at the first twinge." This guide gives you a simple rule you can use during any exercise, explains where the numbers come from, and is honest about what is research and what is our own design.
Is it OK to exercise through pain?
Often, yes, within limits. A systematic review of exercise for chronic musculoskeletal pain looked at this directly. It found nine papers from seven randomized trials with 385 participants that compared painful and pain-free exercise:
We read the abstract only. The review covered chronic musculoskeletal pain, not new injuries, and the short-term difference was small.
The Arthritis Foundation reports a similar pattern in knee and hip osteoarthritis. Exercise is safe and does not damage cartilage or trigger inflammation, pain typically rises during exercise and falls afterward, and in one eight-week program pain first rose by about 10% and then declined steadily as sessions continued. It gives no numeric limit, though: pain should be "tolerable."
So the useful question is not "does it hurt?" but "how much, what kind, and does it settle?"
Where does a 0-to-10 pain rule come from?
The best-known version comes from a 2007 randomized trial in the American Journal of Sports Medicine on Achilles tendon pain, described in a physical therapist-reviewed summary. Thirty-eight people followed the same progressive tendon-loading program. One group kept exercising under a pain-monitoring model, and the other avoided activity for the first 6 weeks. The model's rules were:
- Pain during exercise had to stay below 5 on a 0-to-10 scale.
- Pain after exercise could reach 5 but had to settle by the next morning.
- Pain and stiffness could not rise from one week to the next.
Both groups improved, and the group that kept exercising under the model showed no negative effects. Limits: it was a small trial in one tendon, and we read a secondary summary, not the original paper.
The 2024 Achilles tendinopathy guideline in the Journal of Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy gives no numeric pain threshold and no graded recommendation for pain monitoring. It does say clinicians can assess movement-evoked pain with a 0-to-10 numeric scale, lists pain monitoring to guide activity level as a self-management strategy, and says exercise intensity in a progressive program should be based on the person's pain tolerance and function. We read the first part of that guideline.
In plain terms: the 5-out-of-10 limit and the next-morning check are well supported for tendon rehab and widely borrowed elsewhere. They are not proven for every body part or condition.
The Loosn traffic-light rule
Here is our simplified rule for ongoing aches you are exercising with. Rate your pain from 0 (none) to 10 (the worst you can imagine) during the movement.
Then add the next-morning check:
How to rate your pain consistently
The 0-to-10 scale is simple, but Mayo Clinic Press points out its limits: it is subjective, since a "7" means something different to each person, it captures pain only at the moment you are asked, and it works best paired with other information such as your pain history and your goals. Some tips:
- Rate before you start, so you know your baseline for the day.
- Rate in the middle of the hardest part of the movement, not just at the end.
- Use the same anchor each time. A "4" should mean the same thing on Monday as on Friday.
- Note the type of pain, not only the number: dull and achy, or sharp and pinching.

Soreness versus pain that means "stop"
Cleveland Clinic sports medicine physician Dominic King, DO, separates normal soreness from concerning pain:
Putting the rule into practice
These are worked examples (ours), to show how the lights apply. Loosn's exercise library has the exercises Kai uses, and the exercise and rest timer can pace your sets.
Stop if pain climbs to 6 or higher, turns sharp, spreads down a leg, or you notice new numbness, weakness or tingling. Loosn's how-it-works page says Kai re-evaluates daily from a 30-second check-in on pain, sleep and energy and adjusts your session. Kai, Loosn's AI physio coach, can help you apply a rule like this, but it does not replace an assessment when symptoms are severe, getting worse or unusual.
What this rule does not cover
- Rest versus activity. For when to rest and when to move, see is bed rest bad for back pain?.
- Specific conditions. Different conditions behave differently. See knee arthritis and exercise and can you run with runner's knee?.
- New injuries, surgery or warning signs. The research above is about ongoing musculoskeletal pain. After a new injury or surgery, follow your surgeon's or physical therapist's instructions.
- Flare-ups. For a plan when pain returns, see why back pain keeps coming back and back spasms: the first 48 hours.
If you want to describe your pain clearly to a clinician, see how to describe your pain to a physical therapist.
When to get medical help
Exercise pain that looks like any of the following is not something to push through. Loosn gives no diagnosis.
Emergency: call 911 (or your local emergency number) or go to the emergency department if (Mayo Clinic, MedlinePlus):
- you have new bladder or bowel problems, such as losing control of urine or stool
- your pain starts after a fall or a blow
- you have fever with back pain
- you have trouble walking or lose your balance
- you have chest pain or pressure, trouble breathing or fainting during exercise (our addition, for the clinician to confirm)
(Other common emergency numbers are 999 in the UK, 112 across the EU and 000 in Australia.)
Get seen the same day if (our tiering):
- you have new numbness or weakness in an arm or leg that is getting worse
- you have bruising, swelling or a joint that looks different after exercise
See your provider soon if (Mayo Clinic, MedlinePlus, Cleveland Clinic):
- your pain is getting worse over days or weeks, or does not improve after several days of rest
- pain spreads down a leg, especially below the knee
- you have pain at night that you did not have before
- you have unexplained weight loss with back pain
- pain is severe and medicine does not relieve it
Loosn is not a substitute for assessment when symptoms are severe, getting worse or unusual.
FAQ
How much pain is OK when exercising?
There is no universal number. In one pain-monitoring model used for Achilles tendon rehab, pain had to stay below 5 out of 10 during exercise and settle by the next morning. Loosn's simplified rule is green at 3 or below, yellow at 4 to 5, and red at 6 or above, or any sharp pain. Warning signs always override the numbers.
Is hurt the same as harm?
Not necessarily. A review of 7 randomized trials in people with chronic musculoskeletal pain found painful exercise gave a small short-term pain benefit and no significant difference over the medium or long term, compared with pain-free exercise. That does not make sharp, sudden or worsening pain safe. Cleveland Clinic says not to push through pain during a workout.
Should I stop exercising if it hurts?
Stop if the pain is sharp, sudden, strong or persistent, according to Cleveland Clinic, or if it rates 6 or higher on our rule. Mild, steady discomfort in the 0 to 3 range is usually fine to continue. For 4 to 5, ease the load rather than quitting. If you are unsure, pause and ask a physical therapist or your provider.
What if my pain is worse the next day?
Treat it as a signal to scale back. The Arthritis Foundation's advice is to check pain before, during and 24 hours after exercise, and to reduce intensity or duration if it is still elevated at 24 hours or you are flaring. Repeat the session one level lower, and see your provider if pain keeps climbing or does not improve after several days.
Can exercising through pain make an injury worse?
The reviews we read found no extra harm from moderate pain during exercise in chronic musculoskeletal pain, and the Arthritis Foundation says exercise does not damage joints with osteoarthritis. But those findings do not cover new injuries, surgery or warning signs. Sharp, worsening pain, bruising, fever or numbness should stop exercise and prompt a visit.
Check in with Kai
Download the Loosn app through how Loosn works. Kai uses a daily 30-second check-in on pain, sleep and energy to adjust your session, so you do not have to guess how hard to push.
Jessica Miller, PT, SCS
Author
References
- 1
Smith BE and colleagues.
Should exercises be painful in the management of chronic musculoskeletal pain? A systematic review and meta-analysis. 2017 (abstract read on the University of East Anglia repository record; the page I read did not show journal volume or page numbers, so those are not given here).
https://ueaeprints.uea.ac.uk/id/eprint/63158/ - 2
Silbernagel KG and colleagues.
Continued sports activity, using a pain-monitoring model, during rehabilitation in patients with Achilles tendinopathy: a randomized controlled study. American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2007 (read through a secondary summary on Physical Therapy First, reviewed by PTs; the original paper was not read).
https://physicaltherapyfirst.com/blog/continued-sports-activity-using-a-pain-monitoring-model-during-rehabilitation-in-patients-with-achilles-tendinopathy/ - 3
King D, DO (Cleveland Clinic sports medicine physician, quoted).
Is your exercise causing good or bad pain? How to tell. Cleveland Clinic Health Essentials, 4 April 2025.
https://health.clevelandclinic.org/is-your-exercise-causing-good-or-bad-pain-how-to-tell - 4
Mayo Clinic Press.
Pain scales: valuable tools or problematic practice? Mayo Clinic Press (excerpt from a Mayo Clinic Press book on opioids; no author or date shown on the page).
https://mcpress.mayoclinic.org/opioids/pain-scale/ - 5
Tyrer J.
Exercise and OA joint pain. Arthritis Foundation, 1 October 2021 (report of a July 2021 forum; no reviewer named).
https://www.arthritis.org/science/events-publications/exercise-and-oa-joint-pain - 6
Chimenti RL, Neville C, Houck J, Cuddeford T, Carreira D, Martin RL.
Achilles pain, stiffness, and muscle power deficits: midportion Achilles tendinopathy revision, 2024. Journal of Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy (JOSPT), 2024; 54(12):CPG1-CPG32 (read through a copy hosted by the Academy of Orthopaedic Physical Therapy, APTA; I read the first part only).
https://www.orthopt.org/uploads/content_files/files/Achilles_Pain_revision_2024.pdf - 7
Mayo Clinic.
Back pain: symptoms and causes. Mayo Clinic, 26 September 2024.
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/back-pain/symptoms-causes/syc-20369906 - 8
Ma CB, MD (UCSF); reviewed by Dugdale DC, MD, and the A.D.A.M. Editorial team.
Back pain: MRI. MedlinePlus, reviewed 2 September 2025.
https://medlineplus.gov/ency/article/007493.htm







